Browse articles

Reviews (Books)

By Dineshchandra Sircar, Anukul Chandra Banerjee, Chintaharan Chakravarti, Narendra Krishna Sinha, Dasharatha Sharma

Vol. 19 · No. 3September - 1943pp. 284-292English

Summary

The review section offers critical assessments of recent scholarly books. A. C. Banerjee’s ‘The Eastern Frontier of British India’ is praised for its exhaustive study of British policy on the North‑Eastern frontier between 1792 and 1826 and its use of archival sources, Burmese chronicles and Assamese Buranjis; the reviewer commends its seven‑chapter structure and detailed maps and recommends it to students of Indian colonial history. Dr. Hirananda Sastri’s ‘Nalanda and its Epigraphic Material’ (Memoirs of the Archaeological Survey of India, no. 66) is recognised as an important addition to the literature on Indian epigraphy and archaeology. It is divided into an introductory section on the history of Nalanda and a catalogue of structural remains, seals, inscriptions and sculptures. While acknowledging its utility, the reviewer criticises numerous inaccuracies and hasty readings and points out that an anonymous editor has emended many of Dr. Sastri’s readings. Other reviews touch on the ‘Aitihāsika Jaina‑Kāvya‑Saṅgraha’, a collected edition of historical Jain poems, and on works dealing with colonial Burma and Assam. Collectively, the section highlights the need for rigorous scholarship and careful editing in historical studies and introduces readers to the latest research available in 1943.

Conclusion

The review column summarises and critiques several new works on Indian history. By noting both strengths and shortcomings, it guides readers towards reliable scholarship and underscores the importance of critical engagement with sources.

Original PDF

Inline viewer

Checking source PDF

The viewer will load here if the archive file is reachable.

Continue reading

Related articles

Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Book Review – The Doctrine of the Jainas

By Unexhibited

April - 1979
Vedanta Kesari

Book Review

By Nivedita Raghunath Bhide

Feb 2023
Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Sri Mahavir Jaina Vidyalaya Golden Jubilee Volume (Review)

By Unexhibited

July 1970
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Review: Buddha Purva Ka Bharatiya Itihasa (Part I)

By Ramashankar Tripathi

Deceber - 1942
Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Book Review

By Kastur Chand Lalwani

April 1975
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Reviews

By Jitendra Nath Banerjee

September - 1932