Browse articles

Reviews

By Batakrishna Ghosh, Amareswar Thakur, Kshitish Chandra Chatterjee

Vol. 8 · No. 4December - 1932pp. 798-820English

Summary

This section of the journal provides critical assessments of recent publications in the fields of Indology, linguistics, history and religion. One review examines Helena Willman‑Grabowska’s exhaustive study on nominal compounds in the Śatapatha Brāhmaṇa, praising its comprehensive indexes and its analysis of the role of nominal composition in Vedic prose. Another highlights a Polish Academy monograph on nominal composition across the Brāhmaṇa corpus, noting its meticulous scholarship. Subsequent reviews cover a wide array of topics: an edition of the Burmese Pali text “Sasanavamsa”; a French translation of the Pali “Brahmajāla Sutta” with extensive commentary; and works on the history of the Marathas, the archaeology of South India, and Persian influence on Indian architecture. Reviewers summarise the contents, evaluate methodology and point out strengths and weaknesses. A number of reviews deal with publications on Buddhist philosophy and Tibetan texts, including translations of the Bodhicaryāvatāra and studies on Nāgārjuna. There are assessments of monographs on the geography and inscriptions of the Vijayanagara empire, genealogies of South Indian dynasties and analyses of ancient Sanskrit dramas. A review of K. P. Jayaswal’s work on Hindu polity discusses his interpretation of republican elements in ancient Indian governance. In addition, there are evaluations of new volumes of the Calcutta Oriental Series and reports on excavations at Taxila and Mathura. The reviewers often contextualise the books within broader scholarly debates and identify avenues for further research. Collectively, the section reflects the breadth of modern Indological scholarship in the early 20th century, spanning philology, archaeology, art history, religious studies and politics. It serves not only to inform readers about new literature but also to set standards of critical appraisal.

Conclusion

The reviews section demonstrates the vibrant state of oriental studies by engaging with works on Sanskrit philology, Pali canon, South Indian history, archaeology and Buddhist philosophy. Reviewers commend thorough research while pointing out methodological issues and textual inaccuracies. By summarising and critiquing a diverse range of books, the section guides scholars toward valuable resources and fosters discourse across disciplines. It highlights the importance of rigorous analysis and cross‑cultural comparison in advancing the study of Indian history and culture. Ultimately, the reviews illustrate how collaborative scholarship builds upon previous work to refine our understanding of Asia’s past.

Original PDF

Inline viewer

Checking source PDF

The viewer will load here if the archive file is reachable.

Continue reading

Related articles

Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Book Review – The Doctrine of the Jainas

By Unexhibited

April - 1979
Vedanta Kesari

Book Review

By Nivedita Raghunath Bhide

Feb 2023
Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Sri Mahavir Jaina Vidyalaya Golden Jubilee Volume (Review)

By Unexhibited

July 1970
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Review: Buddha Purva Ka Bharatiya Itihasa (Part I)

By Ramashankar Tripathi

Deceber - 1942
Jain Journal A Quarterly on Jainology

Book Review

By Kastur Chand Lalwani

April 1975
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Reviews

By Jitendra Nath Banerjee

September - 1932