MISCELLANY - Geographical Data in Panini
By Basudeva Upadhyaya
Summary
The text discusses geographical data in Panini's works, highlighting his detailed references to ancient Indian geography, particularly in Afghanistan and surrounding regions. Panini mentions Kapisi (likely corresponding to the Greek Kapisene and Chinese Kia-pi-she) and Varpu (possibly linked to Bannu or Yaneh in modern Afghanistan). The river Suvistu (modern Swat) and the hill-fort of Aornos (possibly Avarana or Arksoda) are identified, though their exact locations remain uncertain. Scholars like Bhandarkar suggest connections between Sanskrit terms and Greek names, such as Arksoda and Archosia. Panini also references Gandhara, with its capital Dvirakd, and notes cities like Salatura (possibly Lalora or Lahul) and Taksasila (modern Taxila), known for its ancient university. The province of Madra (between the Ravi and Chenab rivers) is linked to historical figures like King Adhva and Savitri. The text emphasizes the challenges in identifying ancient locations due to corrupted forms and varying scholarly interpretations.
Conclusion
This study underscores Panini's aphorisms as a valuable yet underexplored source of ancient geographical data, offering insights into early Indian and Afghan regions. By analyzing linguistic patterns and cross-referencing with Greek, Roman, and Chinese accounts, scholars have identified numerous locations, such as Kapisi (Kia-pi-she), Varpu (Fe-la-nu), and Kamboja, with modern names and sites. The research highlights the precision of Panini's references, particularly in detailing rivers like the Suvastu (Swat) and regions like Aornos, while also addressing controversies in identifying places like Arksoda and Archosia. These findings not only enrich our understanding of historical geography but also demonstrate the enduring relevance of Panini's work in reconstructing ancient spatial narratives, bridging linguistic scholarship with archaeological and historical inquiry.