Browse articles

ગીતામાં નિરાકાર-સાકાર તત્ત્વ વિચાર (Part - 2)

By Bansidhar Bhatt

Vol. 272004pp. 107-147Gujarati

Summary

Part 2 of “Geetama Nirakar‑Sakar Tatva Vichar” continues the analysis by focusing on passages in the Bhagavad Gita that affirm a personal, sākāra conception of divinity and exploring how this view complements the nirākāra perspective discussed in Part 1. The author opens by noting that Krishna frequently refers to himself as “Ishvara,” the Lord of all beings, and invites devotees to worship him with loving devotion. Verses such as “man‑manā bhava mad‑bhakto mad‑yājī māṃ namaskuru” underscore a relational theology. The article examines the famous fourfold bhakti path in which Krishna recognises the pious, seekers of material gain, seekers of knowledge and the wise; he declares the wise who see him in all beings as dearest. The author analyses commentaries by Ramanuja and Madhva that interpret these verses as affirming Krishna’s eternal, transcendental form, contrasting them with Shankara’s impersonal reading. He discusses the concept of saguṇa brahman—Brahman with attributes—as a valid manifestation of the ultimate, accessible to devotees through the grace of God. The essay also explores the Gita’s depiction of the cosmic form (Vishvarupa) in Chapter 11, where Krishna reveals a gigantic, awe‑inspiring form encompassing all worlds and beings. This theophany suggests that God’s form is not limited but encompasses the universe itself, bridging nirākāra and sākāra by showing form as infinite. The author emphasises that the Gita does not pit the formless against the formed but presents a hierarchical synthesis: the formless Brahman is the highest reality, but God mercifully manifests in forms to enable devotees to relate. Part 2 also addresses the practical aspects of devotion: chanting God’s name, meditating on his form, engaging in righteous actions and surrendering fruits of actions (karma‑yoga). The article suggests that the Gita advocates a progressive path where devotees may start with ritualistic and devotional practices and gradually realise the oneness of God and self. The author concludes by arguing that recognising the complementary nature of nirākāra and sākāra aspects leads to a more nuanced understanding of the Gita and fosters unity among different Hindu traditions.

Conclusion

Part 2 concludes that the Bhagavad Gita harmonises the formless and the formful aspects of the divine rather than privileging one over the other. The personal deity Krishna invites devotional surrender and reveals his cosmic form, illustrating that God’s form itself is infinite and transcends human limitations. Devotion to a form is not merely a preparatory stage but a legitimate path to realise the formless absolute. By integrating nirākāra and sākāra, the Gita offers an inclusive theology that accommodates diverse spiritual temperaments. The study underscores that such integration can foster harmony among different philosophical schools and enhance spiritual practice.

Article order

In this issue

Vol. 27
1-7Some Aspects of the Rasa‑TheoryTapasvi Shambhuchandra Nandi8-13VisvedevahS. S. Gupta14-24Upavedas – Arthashastra in RamayanaRajalakshmi Srinivasan25-36Mirabai in Gujarati TraditionYajneshwar S. Shastri37-49(E) Utopia and (E) Uchronia in Trisasti‑Salaka‑Purusa‑CaritraRam Krishna Bhattacharya50-58The Victors and the VanquishedD. S. Baya59-68Pracheen Jainagamon mein Charvakadarshan ka Prastutikaran evam SamikshaSagarmal Jain69-80Uttaradhyayansutra mein Pratipadit Karma‑MimansaKamal Kumar Jain81-84Acharya Nemichandra Suri ka VyaktitvaHukam Chand Jain85-95Dharmacharan ka ek Paryay – SatyavaniVasantkumar M. Bhatt96-100Vedarthaghatana and SayanacharyaDinanath Sharma101-106Bauddha Prabrajya–Upasampada: ‘Ehi Bhikkhu’ se ‘Jatticatutthakamma’ takKanjibhai M. Patel106(a)सन्दर्भ ग्रन्थ-सूचिUnexhibited107-147ગીતામાં નિરાકાર-સાકાર તત્ત્વ વિચાર (Part - 1 )Bansidhar Bhatt107-147ગીતામાં નિરાકાર-સાકાર તત્ત્વ વિચાર (Part - 2)Bansidhar BhattCurrent article148-152ગુજરાતની પ્રાચીન કલામાં પ્રાચ્ય લખાણRavi Hajarnis153-167કવિ મંત્રી વસ્તુપાલ અને તેના સમકાલીન કવિઓVibhuti V. Bhatt168-180હેમચંદ્ર : કાવ્યહેતુચિંતન-જૈનદાર્શનિક્તા અને અલંકારશાસ્ત્રીય પરંપરાAjit Thakor181-189દ્વાદશાનુપ્રેક્ષાKokila Hemchand Shah190-194આબુકલ્પD. G. Vedia195-196અભ્યાસ અને અનુસંધાન ક્ષેત્રે આગવું અર્પણMuni Bhuvan Chandra197-201National Workshops on Manuscriptology and Ancient ScriptsKanjibhai M. Patel

Original PDF

Inline viewer

Checking source PDF

The viewer will load here if the archive file is reachable.