Browse articles

Indo-Aryan Invasion of India Not a Myth

By C. V. Vaidya

Vol. 5 · No. 2June - 1929pp. 253-260English

Summary

Responding to critiques of the invasion theory, this article defends the view that Indo‑Aryan speakers migrated into the Indian subcontinent as conquerors. It reviews linguistic evidence showing that Sanskrit and ancient Iranian languages share common roots distinct from Dravidian languages. The author cites archaeological finds from Harappa and Mohenjo‑daro, arguing that differences in skull shape and material culture suggest an influx of new peoples. Ethnological observations of modern Jat, Gujjar and Rajput populations – tall, fair and long‑headed – are compared with Vedic descriptions of Aryans, whereas indigenous groups are described as dark and flat‑nosedfile:///home/oai/share/563005_compressed-189-407.pdf#:~:text=before%20any%20Vedic%20people%20existed%2C. The paper contends that such physical traits are not easily explained by climate alone. It also argues that similarities between the Vedic and Iranian religious lexicon imply a common origin outside India. While acknowledging gaps in archaeological evidence, the author maintains that the invasion theory remains the best explanation for the linguistic and racial changes visible in early historic India.

Conclusion

The article concludes that cumulative linguistic, ethnological and archaeological evidence points to an Indo‑Aryan migration into India. Although the term ‘invasion’ may oversimplify complex processes, the data are difficult to reconcile with a purely indigenous origin of Vedic culture.

Article order

In this issue

Vol. 5 · No. 2
173-181The Sacrificial Wheel taught in the BhagavadgitaJ. Otto Schrader182-187Picture ShowmenAnanda Kentish Coomaraswamy188-218Fine ArtsP. K. Acharya218-224Some Pandya Kings of the Thirteenth CenturyV. R. Ramachandra Dikshitar224-228The Origin of the Varman Dynasty of East BengalDhirendra Chandra Ganguly229-236The Extent of Harsavardhanas EmpireRamesh Chandra Majumdar236-243YagesvaraA. Venkatasubbiah243-248Further Researches into the Antiquity of the VedasV. H. Vader248-253The so-called Indo-Aryan InvasionEdward J. Thomas253-260Indo-Aryan Invasion of India Not a MythC. V. VaidyaCurrent article260-273The Date of ZoroasterJainath Pati274-281On some fiscal terms occurring in the Ancient Indian Land grantsU. N. Ghoshal281-299Ravana and his TribesG. Ramadas299-325Indian Society as pictured in the MrcchakatikaRadha Govinda Basak325-332The Candidas-ProblemMrinal Das Gupta333-341Notes on DravidianL. V. Ramaswami Aiyar341-347Mr C U Wills on the Sambalpur AtharangarhL. P. Pandeya Sharma347-348A Mythical Commentary on Saradatanayas BhavaprakasaK. S. Ramaswami Sastri349-354The Sinhalese Etymological DictionaryD. B. Jayatilaka354-355Some notes on the TattvasamgrahaLouis de La Vallée Poussin355-356Ravanas Lanka located in Central IndiaJogendra Chandra Ghosh356-357Was Nahapana a JainaKamta Prasad Jain358-360Meyer on Manu VIII 235-236Batakrishna Ghosh361-383ReviewsSushil Kumar De, U. N. Ghoshal, Batakrishna Ghosh, Giuseppe Tucci384-389Select Contents of Oriental JournalsUnexhibited390-391Bibliographical NotesUnexhibited

Original PDF

Inline viewer

Checking source PDF

The viewer will load here if the archive file is reachable.

Continue reading

Related articles

The Indian Historical Quarterly

The so-called Indo-Aryan Invasion

By Edward J. Thomas

June - 1929