Browse articles

राज, समाज और हिंसा

Vol. 50 · No. 09September - 2002pp. 09-10Hindi

Summary

The text examines the paradox of rising violence in India despite increased economic prosperity and reduced colonial oppression. It argues that post-independence, while material conditions improved and the fear of state repression diminished, violence has not decreased. The author contends that contemporary violence is not a result of poverty or technology, but stems from a failure of the state to establish a genuine dialogue with society. Groups, feeling humiliated and empowered, resort to violence because the state has not maintained a meaningful connection with them. The text traces a history of violent episodes from the Partition riots, the Telangana movement, and the Razakar insurgency, to later conflicts in Nagaland, Mizoram, Assam, Tripura, and Punjab. It argues that these conflicts, both ancient and modern, are fundamentally about one group’s desire for dominance over another, not about poverty. The author asserts that poverty is often a consequence of violence, not its cause, and that some forms of poverty are chosen for ideals. True violence-driven poverty occurs when one group strips another of its cultural and political rights. The text concludes by invoking Gandhi’s view of India’s inherently non-violent culture, where non-violence is a central tenet of its worldview, despite the historical occurrence of wars and conflicts.

Conclusion

The document argues that violence in India is not a result of poverty or technological change, but stems from a desire for political-cultural dominance and the restoration of lost prestige. It challenges the notion that India is inherently non-violent, pointing to historical and ongoing conflicts as evidence of deep-seated group tensions. The implications are significant: addressing violence requires confronting the underlying lust for supremacy and the failure of the state to foster a unified national identity. The outcome, if this trend continues, could be a society requiring constant policing, undermining the Gandhian ideal of a peaceful, integrated nation. Ultimately, the text calls for a re-evaluation of the roots of conflict, moving beyond economic explanations to focus on cultural and political grievances.

Original PDF

Inline viewer

Checking source PDF

The viewer will load here if the archive file is reachable.