Browse articles

The Authorship of the Anunyasa

By Kshitish Chandra Chatterjee

Vol. 7 · No. 2June - 1931pp. 418-419English, Sanskrit

Summary

This article, written by Kshitis Chandra Chatterji, discusses the authorship of the Anu­nyāsa, a grammatical treatise sometimes conflated with the Tantrapradīpa of Maitreya Rakṣita. In the introduction to his edition of the Kāśikāvivaraṇa­pañcikā, Prof. Sriscandra Chakravarti observed that some scholars identify the Anu­nyāsa with the Tantra, but Chatterji argues that the two works are distinct. He cites quotations from Stradeva’s Paribhāṣā­vṛtti (Benares edition) showing that the Anu­nyāsa is attributed to an author referred to as “Upa.” The passages discuss technical points of Pāṇinian grammar and indicate that “Upa” (possibly Upavarṣa) wrote a commentary distinct from the Tantrapradīpa. Chatterji points out that various authors refer to the Tantrapradīpa and Anu­nyāsa separately and that the linguistic evidence does not support merging them. He concludes that Upavarṣa is the probable author of the Anu­nyāsa and that conflating it with Maitreya Rakṣita’s work obscures the textual history of grammatical commentaries. The article emphasises the importance of careful source criticism in determining authorship and warns against accepting traditional attributions without examining textual evidence.

Conclusion

Through analysis of quotations in medieval grammatical commentaries, the author argues that the Anu­nyāsa and the Tantrapradīpa are separate works. The Anu­nyāsa is attributed to “Upa,” likely Upavarṣa, while the Tantrapradīpa is by Maitreya Rakṣita. This clarification helps trace the lineage of grammatical scholarship and underscores the need to distinguish between similarly named texts when reconstructing intellectual history.

Article order

In this issue

Vol. 7 · No. 2
214-244Origin of the Bell-CapitalAchyuta Kumar Mitra245-253Topography in the PuranasSashi Bhusan Chaudhuri253-258Dvaidhibhava in the KautiliyaNarendra Nath Law259-286Bodhisattva Pratimoksa SutraNalinaksha Dutt287-300The First Saka of CitodSubimal Chandra Datta301-308Mandana, Suresvara and Bhavabhuti : The Problem of their IdentityDinesh Chandra Bhattacharya309-318Some Notes on Skanda-KarttikeyaManmatha Mukhopadhyay319-330Kulasekhara of KeralaK. Rama Pisharoti331-333A Surya Icon from a Dasavatara Temple, PaganNiharranjan Roy334-342Vilvamangalam SvamiyarsA. Govinda Warrier343-358Early Visnuism and Narayaniya WorshipMrinal Das Gupta359-362Ganga in Ceylon and IndiaJ. C. De362-364An Early Supporter of ShivajiJadunath Sarkar365-366The Webbed Finger of BuddhaAnanda Kentish Coomaraswamy367-370A Few Evidences on the Age of the KathavatthuDwijendra Lal Barua370-371The Age of the Visnu PuranaV. R. Ramachandra Dikshitar371-376More on ManimekhalaSylvain Levi377-379Derivation of PaliS. V. Viswanatha380-383Problems of the NatyasastraHarihara V. Trivedi384-388Technical Terms in the Hindu Revenue SystemU. N. Ghoshal389-410The English Translation of the KautiliyaNarendra Nath Law410-412An Inscription dated in the Reign of Emperor Muhammad ShahDineshchandra Sircar412-412Candasutinam in the Nanaghat Cave InscriptionDineshchandra Sircar413-418The BhagavrttiKshitish Chandra Chatterjee418-419The Authorship of the AnunyasaKshitish Chandra ChatterjeeCurrent article420-427ReviewsAnanda Kentish Coomaraswamy, Subimal Chandra Datta428-432Select Contents of Oriental JournalsUnexhibited433-434Bibliographical NotesUnexhibited

Original PDF

Inline viewer

Checking source PDF

The viewer will load here if the archive file is reachable.

Continue reading

Related articles

The Indian Historical Quarterly

Indra and Panini

By B. N. Krishnamurti Sharma

June - 1932
The Indian Historical Quarterly

The Bhagavrtti

By Kshitish Chandra Chatterjee

June - 1931
The Indian Historical Quarterly

King Narasimha of Gaunda and the study of the Mahabhasya in Bengal

By Jogendra Chandra Ghosh

December - 1933
The Indian Historical Quarterly

Max Muller's Introduction to the Rgveda-Pratisakhya

By Batakrishna Ghosh

December - 1927